Pay off a 7.11% mortgage or invest? The break-even is 7.91%
At today's 7.11% average rate, investing in a taxable account (15% tax on growth) beats extra mortgage payments only above about 7.91% a year before tax.
On this page 5 sections
Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed rate averaged 7.11% as of November 12, 2026. At that rate, extra principal payments earn a certain 7.35% a year once monthly compounding is counted, and an investment taxed at 15% on its growth has to earn about 7.91% a year before tax just to tie. On a $300,000 balance with 25 years left and $500 extra a month, a steady 7% return leaves the investor $33,265 behind the household that paid the loan down. The mortgage interest deduction would lower that bar, but only for households that itemize, and against the 2026 standard deduction ($32,200 for a married couple) a couple with this loan and $11,000 of state and property taxes falls $15 short of itemizing even in the first year, so the deduction is worth nothing to them.
The numbers
The break-even and payoff figures come from the MoneyVibe pay off the mortgage or invest calculator, which does not count the mortgage interest deduction; the deduction figures further down come from a separate calculator, the loan's year-by-year interest from its amortization schedule, and a few shortcut calculations, flagged where they appear. The payoff calculator spends the same cash both ways: the scheduled payment plus the extra, every month, until the original term ends. One route sends the extra to principal and, once the loan is gone, invests the whole payment; the other invests the extra from the first month. Growth is taxed once at the end at the rate you choose. Inputs for the main example: $300,000 left at 7.11%, 25 years remaining (a $2,141.44 monthly payment), $500 extra a month, 15% tax on growth. The example is a hypothetical $300,000 balance with 25 years left, priced at today's 30-year average for illustration; a new loan with a shorter term would carry a different rate, and an older loan probably carries a lower one, so substitute your own. These are examples, not forecasts.
| Situation | Break-even return, before tax |
|---|---|
| 3.00% loan, taxable account (15% on growth) | 3.42% |
| 5.00% loan, taxable account | 5.62% |
| 6.00% loan, taxable account | 6.71% |
| 7.11% loan, Roth account (no tax on growth) | 7.35% |
| 7.11% loan, taxable account | 7.91% |
Paying down at 7.11% clears the loan in month 190, 9 years and 2 months early, and saves $142,725 of interest. What the comparison asks is whether the investments built from the start beat the larger investments built later, after tax. At different steady returns, with the same loan and the same $500:
| Steady yearly return | Which route ends ahead after 25 years, after tax | By how much |
|---|---|---|
| 5% | Pay down | $86,165 |
| 7% | Pay down | $33,265 |
| 8% | Invest | $3,565 |
| 9% | Invest | $49,194 |
| 10% | Invest | $105,364 |
The 7% row is $15,888 in today's dollars at 3% inflation.
Why it works this way
Paying down is a return equal to the loan's rate, with no risk. Each extra dollar of principal stops interest from being charged on that dollar for the rest of the loan. A 7.11% mortgage rate is quoted as a nominal rate charged monthly, which works out to 7.35% a year, so even a tax-free account has to earn 7.35% to break even (the Roth row above).
Tax on the investment's growth raises the bar. IRS Topic 409 says the rate on most net capital gains is no higher than 15% for most individuals, with 20% above the income thresholds it lists. Topic 559 adds a 3.8% net investment income tax for modified adjusted gross income above $200,000 single or $250,000 joint. Between that threshold and the 20% bracket the combined rate is 18.8%. The interest you avoid by paying down is never taxed, so an investment has to earn enough extra to cover its tax: 7.91% at 15%, 8.31% at 23.8% (20% plus 3.8%).
The deduction only counts if you itemize. IRS Publication 936 sets the conditions; the two that matter here: home mortgage interest on a secured loan on your main or second home is deductible only if you file Form 1040 and itemize on Schedule A, and only on up to $750,000 of acquisition debt ($375,000 married filing separately; $1 million for debt from before December 16, 2017). The IRS's tax year 2026 release sets the standard deduction at $32,200 for married couples filing jointly, $16,100 for single filers and $24,150 for heads of household. Mortgage interest only saves tax to the extent that all itemized deductions together pass those amounts.
Here is what that means for the same $300,000, 7.11% loan, which charges $21,185 of interest in its first year, run through the MoneyVibe standard vs itemized deduction calculator with no charitable gifts or medical costs:
| Household (2026) | State and local tax plus property tax | First-year mortgage interest | Itemized total | Standard deduction | First-year tax saved by the interest |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Married, joint, $150,000 income | $11,000 | $21,185 | $32,185 | $32,200 | $0 |
| Single, $120,000 income | $9,500 | $21,185 | $30,685 | $16,100 | $3,209 |
The joint household's itemized total is $15 below its standard deduction, so it takes the standard deduction and the interest saves it nothing in year one. The interest falls every year, so the gap only widens: in year two the itemized total is $31,853. For this couple the deduction never applies, and the after-tax mortgage rate is the full 7.11%, which leaves the break-even at 7.91%.
The single filer is different. Holding the 2026 standard deduction at $16,100 for every year (in practice it rises with inflation, which ends the benefit sooner), itemizing wins by $14,585 in year one and keeps winning into year 21, at a 22% marginal rate, saving $3,209 in year one, $2,322 in year ten and $103 in year 21; the benefit is gone by year 22 at a fixed standard deduction, sooner with inflation increases. The usual shortcut, treating the loan as if it cost 7.11% × (1 - 0.22) = 5.55% for its whole life, gives a break-even of 6.22%. That is a rough bound on the deduction's effect, a payoff-calculator run at a 5.55% rate as a shortcut, not a model of the deduction: it assumes every dollar of interest is deducted at 22% every year, and in fact the deduction shrinks each year and is gone by year 22 even at a fixed standard deduction. This household's break-even probably sits between 6.22% and 7.91%, but no calculator here models the deduction over the life of the loan, so treat that range as an estimate.
What changes the answer
- Your mortgage rate. It moves the answer most: with the same balance, term and extra, the break-even is 3.42% on a 3% loan, 5.62% on a 5% loan and 7.91% at 7.11%. A household that locked a low rate years ago faces a very different question from one that bought this year.
- Years left on the loan. With the same $300,000 at 7.11% and $500 extra, the break-even is 8.34% with 10 years left, 8.18% with 15, 7.91% with 25 and 7.81% with 30. It falls as the term lengthens.
- Where the money is invested. A Roth account with qualified withdrawals takes the tax off growth and drops the bar to 7.35%. Higher earners who owe 20% plus the 3.8% investment income tax face 8.31%. The calculator does not model traditional 401(k) or IRA money, where every withdrawal is taxed. Gains that fall in the 0% long-term rate band (IRS Topic 409 lists the 2025 limits, up to $48,350 for a single filer and $96,700 for a joint return) face the same 7.35% bar as the Roth.
- Whether you itemize. A joint filer near the $32,200 line gains little or nothing from the deduction; a single filer with the same loan can gain enough to pull the break-even toward 6.22%. For 2026 the cap on state and local tax deductions is $40,400 (it was $40,000 for 2025), reduced above $505,000 of modified AGI but never below $10,000, which pushes more households in high-tax states past the standard deduction. The law sets the cap back to $10,000 from 2030, so a household that itemizes only because of the higher cap may lose the benefit partway through the loan. Run your own Schedule A figures before assuming either.
- Risk and access. The 7.91% is a steady return; real returns swing and can be negative for years, while a prepayment's return is fixed. Money paid into the house cannot be spent again without selling or borrowing, so the comparison does not price liquidity at all.
What to do first
- Take your rate, balance and years left from your latest mortgage statement and enter them, with the extra you can afford, in the pay off the mortgage or invest calculator. Read the break-even return it reports.
- Check whether you actually itemize: put last year's state and local taxes, property tax, mortgage interest (Form 1098) and gifts into the standard vs itemized deduction calculator. If the standard deduction wins, your after-tax mortgage rate is your full rate.
- Compare the break-even with a return you would accept losing sleep over, not the best year you remember. Keep an emergency fund first either way, and if a workplace plan offers a match, that match is usually worth capturing before you weigh this question.
What this does not model
Adjustable rates, refinancing, prepayment penalties, property tax and insurance, PMI, state income tax on gains, annual taxes on dividends, inflation increases to the standard deduction, and the swings of real markets. The tax on growth is a single rate applied at the end, and the deduction cases above assume no other itemized items beyond those listed.
Next steps: run your own loan in the pay off the mortgage or invest calculator, read the library chapter on prepaying the mortgage or investing, or see the glossary entries for the standard deduction, the long-term capital gains rate and opportunity cost.
Not tax or legal advice. Mortgage rate from Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey, which averaged 7.11% as of November 12, 2026; federal rules from IRS Publication 936 (2025), the IRS tax year 2026 inflation adjustments release, IRS Topics 409 and 559, and Public Law 119-21 (SALT cap), all read on November 13, 2026. Confirm with a tax professional before acting.